You are here

Animal mistreatment in Petra

Jan 25,2018 - Last updated at Jan 25,2018

Regarding the article published in The Jordan Times titled "Animal welfare under scrutiny in Petra after reports of abuse" on January 18, it is not just about new stables, lighter carriages and animal-friendly harnesses. It's about overloading and overworking the 12 carriage horses in the Siq and the many donkeys which climb up the 900 steps to the Monastery. 

When the carriages were first introduced, they were intended only for people who were unable to walk all the way to the Treasury, and only two people should ride with the driver at a steady trot. Instead, anybody including whole families rides in them and some unknowledgeable tourists encourage the drivers to whip the horses into a fast canter uphill on the way back. Then they turn them around after dropping the people off, and go straight back down with more tourists, without even a breather for the animals.  If they take them to the clinic for a drink it wastes their time and loses a trip. The horses are exhausted by evening. Nobody monitors how many trips they do. Four noiseless golf carts were bought three years ago, but the men preferred their horses as they didn't have to waste time charging them up, earning less money. Golf carts do not do the damage that horses' iron-shod hooves do, nor do they emit fumes as other vehicles do.

On 30, 10, 2014 a "Care for Petra" campaign was launched after many meetings. It included the above, respecting the site, and child labour. Yet young boys are still in charge of many of the donkeys climbing the steep eroded steps up to the Monastery. The donkeys' hooves damage the steps. The boys do not care about very heavy people riding the donkeys, which should only carry up to 50 kg. 

Laws mean nothing to the boys, and fines for cruelty are around five to 7JD. 

No-one has ever been jailed for cruelty. 

353 horses and 30 camels are licensed and each wears a number. Donkeys have no licences and no numbers. Cruelty harms Jordan's image. Mahatma Gandhi said: "A country is judged by the way it treats its animals". 

 

Chris Larter. 

 

Amman.

up
327 users have voted.

Comments

When we were in Petra in 2015 we witnessed the same abuse of the animals especially of the donkeys and tried to react to it, knowing of course that the boys and men who mistreated them weren't interested in any comment. I therefore suggest that it should be explained to tourists at the entry of Petra by means of noticeable signs what harm it means the animals when making use of the rides. Furthermore authorities should make regular controls of the number of carriages and vets should examine the animals regularly. Perhaps authorities may find volunteers to support them, for it is no pleasure visiting Petra
witnessing how animals are treated.

Children who inflict this kind of cruelty to the donkeys are apparently not being corrected, on the contrary they are rewarded with money and tips by the tourists. As much as this is a major abuse to the welfare of these loyal and beautiful animals it is more disconcerting that young children are adopting an abusive mindset. Studies have shown that cruelty to animals in young children is a sign of sociopathy.

Add new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
2 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Newsletter

Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.